All manuscripts are handled electronically throughout the consideration process. Elsevier is currently publishing not only the time to 1st decision and publication but also the CiteScore, Impact Factor, and Acceptance rate of their journals. It only takes a minute to sign up. No news is good news? Research suggests that . A final decision of acceptance or rejection of the revised manuscript is made by the editors as soon as they conclude that they have sufficient information at hand for doing so. Your manuscript entitled "xxxxxxxxx" has now been seen again by our original reviewers, whose comments are appended below. The criteria for a paper to be sent for peer-review are that the results seem novel, arresting (illuminating, unexpected or surprising), and that the work described has both immediate and far-reaching implications. Thus it is not surprising that the first reaction to a rejection letter is often a sense that the editors must have made a mistake. Weigh all of your options and look at the merits of the rejection. Decision pending means that the decision is pending.They havent decided yet. If Nature's editors agree to reconsider a paper, the other original referee(s) will have the chance to see and comment on the report of the referee who is the subject of the complaint. Enter the email address you signed up with and we'll email you a reset link. What does the status 'under editor evaluation' mean? We suggest that authors send proofs to co-authors for them to check, but request that changes among the co-authors are coordinated so that only one author communicates with Nature and only one set of corrections is sent. My paper was published in a journal in 2021 october. Subscribe and get curated content that will give impetus to your research paper. If the manuscript was transferred to us from another Nature Research journal, we will not publish reviewer reports or author rebuttals of versions of the manuscript considered by the originating Nature Research journal. ensure that the figures and tables are clear and will fit in the space available. We understand your anxiety :-) However, the. If the journal lowers its threshold for publication, its reputation will decline, devaluing the achievements of thousands of previously accepted authors. ensure that the paper is at the length specified by the manuscript editor (including number of figures). I have experience with the manuscript submission process, from submission to peer review, to acceptance/rejection. How much time does the scientific journal 'Nature' take from - Quora Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content: Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article. If a paper was rejected because the authors failed to persuade the referees that they had excluded alternative interpretations, then new data or analyses are likely to be required for the appeal to have any chance of success. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Editor decision started might sound like the editor is going to bench reject your paper, but thats not necessarily the case. A vital, and often overlooked, aspect of peer review is that in the current system, peer reviewers are normally not paid for their work. Rejection is of course a fact of life for all scientists, particularly when they submit their work to highly selective journals; in less than five years since its inception, Nature Neuroscience . As opposed to an editor, a peer reviewer advises the researcher of how he would have conducted his research, and what research methods would have made a difference. Icons made by various authors from www.flaticon.com, Experiential Live Edit: How to improve Biomed manuscripts. It doesnt mean anything other than the editor has started to look at your paper. Currently, the status is "Peer Review Over" and "Decision Started" since more than 15 days. you're still in the running. Committee for Health, Social Services and Public Safety A decision of major revisions means you'll need to do some heavier work. Many journals now rely on editorial management systems, which are supposed to support the administration and decision making of editors, while aiming at making the process of communication faster and more transparent to both reviewers and authors. Nature has space to publish only 8% or so of the 200 papers submitted each week, hence its selection criteria are rigorous. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Do the revisions and resubmit. Authors often ask for a new referee to be consulted, particularly in cases where two referees have been used and one is negative, the other positive. //-->General Average and Risk Management in Medieval and Early Modern Does this mean a rejection letter is about to come? b. [CDATA[> sciencenature - Editors encourage authors in highly technical disciplines to provide a slightly longer summary paragraph that descries clearly the basic background to the work and how the new results have affected the field, in a way that enables nonspecialist readers to understand what is being described. In replying to the referees comments, authors are advised to use language that would not cause offence when their paper is shown again to the referees, and to bear in mind that if a point was not clear to the referees and/or editors, it is unlikely that it would be clear to the nonspecialist readers of Nature. I submitted a manuscript to a Nature journal six days ago. The author submits a manuscript and it receives a tracking number. For our last submission the decision took 25 days for which the editor apologized. [CDATA[// > More importantly, in the rejection letter it was evident that the Editor had taken the time to read through our manuscript and had given it some thought . Improve this answer. Space in Nature is extremely limited, and so format requirements must be strictly observed, as advised by the editor handling the submission, and detailed in the manuscript formatting guide. The reviewers only make recommendations. Editor rejected manuscript claiming it is similar to a not-yet-published manuscript (that I haven't seen). resubmitnoveltyresubmit, 4. The editor will then decide whether to accept your work as is, request minor or major revisions, or reject the paper due to unresolvable concerns. Authors should note that as Nature is an interdisciplinary journal, referees for a paper are chosen for different reasons, for example a technical expert and a person who has a general overview of a field might both referee the same paper. The finals started yesterday. PRX editors make every effort to arrive at a clear decision on the disposition of a manuscript within a reasonable time. If the authors feel that they have a strong scientific case for reconsideration (if the referees have missed the point of the paper, for example) they can appeal the decision in writing. Although optional, the cover letter is an excellent opportunity to briefly discuss the importance of the submitted work and why it is appropriate for the journal. Once your manuscript passes the initial quality check, we assign it to a member of Editorial Board, who is an active researcher in your field. Authors subsequently receive an e-proof, including the figures, and can also download a PDF proof of the layout. Ellie Bergstrom, PhD on Twitter good luck!! The categories includeroughly in order of persuasivenessnew data or analysis, factual errors by referees or editors, disagreement with technical criticisms, evidence of referee bias, procedural concerns and disputes over novelty or significance. Cactus Communications. Nature (journal) - Wikipedia Was your paper accepted? //--> How do I align things in the following tabular environment?